Bande ne to sahi hi to bola ha Sajid bhai. Agr Dhn div ka freight revenue se koi matlab hi ni ha ECR ka to ECR DHN div ko chhor q ni dete?? ECR se dekha ni ja rah to ECR ko proposal dene boliye RB ko taki ECR se Dhn div ko alag kar de
IRI pe is tara ka koi v utpatang logic de do ap but fact yehi ha ki DHN div bas revenue pe bhi ECR bad raha ha. Yeh jo trophy wagera ka naam le rahe yeh sab Dhn div k lia aata ha lrkin badle ma ECR ghanta deta ha Dhn div ko

---

Yeh kya bol rhe Sajid bhai. Ap to Patna se ho. Apka to MoTD history name bhi Sampoona Kranti Sf exp likha ha

---

Dhn div ER se ECR jane ma ER kuch chahta tab bhi kar ni pata qki us time RM Nitish Kumar the. Nitish Kumar ko apne state k liye ek zone chahiye tha aur us zone ma feasible banwane k liye DHN div. Feasible isliye qki Dhn div ni hota to ECR heavily loss making zone hoti. Politicians se bada kuch hota ha kya India ma??

---

Yeh sk sf ex ka matlab kya ha yeh to sabko pata ha. Vese bhi apka writting style dekh k pata lag jata ha ap kon ho. Ab agr ap ni man na chate to wo alag baat

---

Bgp division ho ya na ho mujhe usse kuch ni. Ma bas is Jamtara wale bande ko support kar rha tha. Bihar khud apne zone ma Jharkhand ko regular train ni deta lekin inka khud ka station ko 1 Covid spl ni milne par yeh log hungama karne aa jate ha

---

Bas hype create kia gaya ha last 2-3 din se. Bas 9-10 mahine pehle hi Seemachal accident ma 7 logo ki maut hui thi. Last mahine hi Hyderabad MMTS aur Hundry exp ka accident ma LP ka maut hui thi. Aur yeha kaha gaya ha ki last 12 mahine ma koi maut ni hui ha

---

"Indian Railways has recorded zero passenger deaths in rail accidents in 2019" - mujhe to news ma yehi dikh ra ha first line

---

Temporary hota to DE1 dete jese LHB k time diye the. Ye to permanent hi lag ra ha

---

Yeha CC pe kab add hua uska ni, train ma kab add kia gaya ha ye coach wo puch rahe ha.

---

Bihar Dhn div ko revenue deta ha?? LOL
Dhn div ka pura revenue CIC section se aata ha. Pehle thoda knowledge gain kijia DHN div ko lekar

---

Ap hi boldo konsa portion aata ha Bihar ka DHN div ma aur kitna revenue aata ha woha se. Bina jane bolte ka yehi natiza hota ha. Dhn div ka 70% revenue JH se aata ha, Karanpur aur Jharia coalfields se, baki 30% Singrauli coalfields se aati ha. Bihar se 0% revenue aati ha

---

Ap topic se bahar ja rae ho. Apne kaha Bihar se DHN div ko revenue milti ha, kaha par milti ha wo batao ap.
Baki mene to khud hi kaha ki Singrauli coalfield se 30% revenue aati ha DHN ki. Dhn div ko kaha kaha se paisa milti ha ye mujhe batane ki jarurat ni ha, wo to mujhe apse jyada pata ha. Ap pehle ye batao Bihar se kaha revenue milti ha DHN ko??

---

Aese faltu ka baat karna pasand ha apko. Tab se hi keh ra hu 70% JH se aati ha baki Singrauli se. Singrauli agr JH ma hi hoti to alag se uska naam q le ra hu itne time se. Matlab apko itne der tak pata bhi ni tha ki Singrauli MP ma aati ha. Waah!! Is knowledge se tab se debate kar rae ho
Anyways, sabko hata do, tab v jitna area aur revenue bachega wo kafi ha ek alag division aur zone ko banwane k lia

---

Ha uska check ki ha mene. Asn div ma jyadatar WB ka hi area ha. 650km ma 200 k aspas JH ha aur baki ka santhal pargana MLDT aur HWH div ma ha. Santhal Pargana ka area ASN, MLDT aur HWH div se hatakar DHN div se merge kardena chaiye. Baki jitna rahega wo Asn div ma reh sakta ha

---

Koderma-Madhupur line ha na. Madhupur-Koderma/Giridih, Chittaranjan-Madhupur-Jasidih, Jasidih-Dumka-Rampurhat, Dumka-Barahat/Godda aur Deoghar-Banka - in sections ko DHN div ma merge kar dena chaiye. Baki Sitarampur-Pradhankunta aur Banka-Bhagalpur ER ma reh sakta ha, usma bada koi station ni ha JH ka

---

Ha ER to sahi ma achha tha. Pehle jab ECR form hui thi tab laga tha DHN ko ER se achha treatment ECR ma milega. Ab jake tab kitna bada galti hui thi samajh aata ha. Lekin ab jab naya zone ka baat a hi ra ha to JH based ka demand karna better ha. Agr tab v RB ni mana to DHN ko ER se merge karne ka demand kia ja hi sakta ha. Agr bas DHN div ka JH wala portion kisi dusre zone ma jae tab v kitna revenue generate ho sakta ha ye upar wale bande ko samajh a hi ni rah ha

---

Aur reality ye ha ki DHN se MP portion ko hata do (qki UP aur Bihar ko hatane se ghanta fark padta ha), tab v Dhn div ka revenue humongous hi rehga. Ek baat yaad rakhiyega samundar se chullu bhar pani hatane se wo sukha ni ban jata. Baki manna na manna apki marzi. Btw apne kaha tha Bihar contribute karta ha DHN div ma, mene bas uska protest kia tha (yaad ni ha to check karlo phirse mera first blog) qki Bihar k 8-10 Nsg 6 aur halt station se DHN div ko kuch ni milta

---

Mene MP portion lekar as such kuch kaha hi ni unse. Pehle se hi keh rah hu ki DHN div ka 70% revenue JH se ha baki Singrauli se. Lekin unka kehna ha "Bihar" aur "UP" ko hatane se DHN div dhaas jaega. Ha Singrauli ka kafi contribution hota ha lekin agr Singrauli k sath Dhn div 15k cr kama rah ha to Dhn div k bina 10k cr kama hi lega. JH portion ma v Jharia aur Karanpur CF ha jaha se achha khasa revenue aata ha, wo kafi ha ek zone ka operating ratio sahi karne ma. Mera kehne ka bas yehi matlab tha

---